Explain the concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin.

The concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin.  The idea of liberty as a core principle of liberal thought, is most commonly understood as ‘absence of restraints’. The notion of liberty emerged in the context of the establishment of new socio-economic and political relationships in modern Europe. At the basis of the notion was the idea of a rational individual, capable of taking reasoned decisions. The concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin. The rational individual, it was thought, was capable of self-determination; in other words, capable of taking decisions which concerned his or her self. In order to develop his capacities, the individual required freedom from all kinds of social, political and economic constraints.

The concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin. Thus, the idea of liberty as absence of restraints, or a sphere of autonomy of the individual, developed. At the same time, however, the fact that within a social organization the individual is not alone and exists in relation with other individuals, required that an equal claim of other individuals to their spheres of autonomy should be recognized. In order that the respective claims of all individuals to autonomy can be realized with minimum conflict, it was imperative that a system of restraints and regulation was worked out and adhered to by everyone.

The theories of social contract put forward by philosophers like Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau put forth the idea of liberty as absence of constraints. At the same time, they also proposed the framework within which individual freedom was to unfold. Thus, the idea of political community was based on a simultaneous recognition of the capacities and autonomy of individuals and the imperatives that all should be subjected to a common set of constraints on their liberty. The concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin.

ISAIAH BERLIN AND THE TWO CONCEPTS OF LIBERTY

In his now classic Two Concepts of Liberty (first published in 1958) Isaiah Berlin tries to reconcile the negative and positive notions of liberty, i.e., the notion of liberty as the absence of restraints with the various views pertaining to its operation within the social context.

On the other hand, the positive sense is concerned with the answer to the question: ‘what, or who, is the source of control or interference that can determine someone to do, or be, this rather than that?’ (1969, p.122). Positive liberty, on the other hand, does not interpret freedom as simply being left alone but as ‘self-mastery’. The theory involves a special theory of the self. The personality is divided into a higher and a lower self. The higher self is the source of an individual’s genuine and rational long-term goals, while the lower self caters to his irrational desires which are short-lived and of transient nature.

A person is free to the extent that his higher self, is in command of his lower self. Thus, a person might be free in the sense of not being restrained by external forces, but remains a slave to irrational appetites; as a drug addict, an alcoholic or a compulsive gambler might be said to be unfree. 

    The main feature of this concept is its openly evaluative nature, its use is specifically tied to ways of life held to be desirable. The idea of positive liberty involves a special interpretation of the self and assumes not just that there is a realm of activity towards which the individual ought to direct herself/himself. The concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin.

Conclusion

The idea of liberty is at the core of liberal thought, which places the rational individual at its center and draws a boundary between the individual and his/her sphere of autonomy, the state and the society. Liberty in its common understanding means an ‘absence of constraints’.

In other words, it signifies a condition in which an individual who is capable of taking reasoned decisions pertaining to his/her own affairs is free to take any action without and restraints from outside, including state and society. At the same time, however, the notion of liberty, evolved at the same time as the idea of a political community and political authority. 

The concept of liberty in the writings of Isaiah Berlin. This simultaneous evolution has meant an equal recognition of the liberties of all individuals and the understanding that reasonable restrictions on individual liberty could be justified on the grounds that they provided the conditions in which individual liberty could be enjoyed without conflict. The idea of liberty as the absence of restraints is associated with a ‘negative’ notion of liberty.

• Tweet
• Share
• Share
• Share