Do you agree with Plato’s criticism that the Iliad offers no morals
Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, Plato was the foremost celebrated disciple of Socrates. By his time the glory of Athenian art and literature, illustrated within the works of artists like Phidias and Polygnotus and writers like Aeschylus, Sophocles, Euripides, and Aristophanes, was on the
wane, and their place was taken by philosophy and oratory, of which the chief
priests were Parmenides, Empedocles, and Socrates, among the philosophers, and
Gorgias, Antiphon, and Lysias, among the orators.
Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, Confronted with the decline
in national character and therefore the standards of social and public life,
the philosophers especially discussed an excellent sort of matters, of concern
to the citizen and therefore the state, applying the test of reason to every. Plato’s
Criticism That No Morals, Socratcs heads all of them by his dispassionate quest
of truth, which frequently challenged many a established belicf and convention.
Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, Among these general
inquiries, the worth of literature to society and its nature and functions also
came certain their due share of consideration. the idea of Forms, expounded
systematically within the Phaedo and therefore the Republic, are often
summarized as follows. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, The familiar world of
objects which surrounds us, and which we apprehend by our senses, isn't
independent and self-sufficient. Indeed, it's not the important world (even
though the objects in it exist) because it's dependent upon another world, the
realm of pure Forms or ideas, which may be apprehended only by reason and not
by our bodily sense perceptions.
The connection between the realms can best be illustrated
using examples from geometry: any triangle or square that we construct using
physical instruments is sure to be imperfect. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals,
at the most it can merely approximate the perfect triangle which is ideal and
which is perceived not by the senses but by reason: the perfect triangle isn't
a object but an idea , an idea, a Form. consistent with Plato, the planet of
Forms, being changeless and eternal, alone constitutes reality.
Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, it's the planet of
essences, unity, and universality, whereas the physical world is characterized
by perpetual change and decay, mere existence (as against essence),
multiplicity and particularity. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, As literature
is an art, like painting, sculpture, et al. , what Plato thought of art
generally deserves the primary consideration. it's intimately bound up with
what's called his Theory of Ideas. Ideas, he says within the Republic, are the
last word reality.
Things are conceived as ideas before they take practical
shape as things. A tree, thus, is nothing quite a concrete embodiment of its
image in idea. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, the thought of everything
therefore is its original pattern, and therefore the thing itself its copy.
because the copy ever come short of the first , it's once faraway from reality.
Now art– literature, painting, sculpture — reproduces but
things ‘as near pasttime’, the primary in words, subsequent in colours, and
therefore the last in stone. So it merely copies a copy: it's twice faraway
from reality. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, Things themselves being
imperfect copies of the ideas from which they spring, their reproduction in art
must be more imperfect still. They take me faraway from reality instead of
towards it. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, Since art serves no useful
purpose in society, Plato views art as useless. Art added neither knowledge nor
intellectual value.
Art is actually deceptive and potentially dangerous. the
entire aim of art is to deceive. Success is achieved when the spectator
mistakes an imitation of reality. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, Art is
unconcerned with morality, sometimes even teaching immoral lessons as within
the case of The Iliad. Poetry isn't just to supply pleasure. It should teach
some morals. Plato’s Criticism That No Morals, It should contribute to the
knowledge. A poet should even be good teacher. Plato suggests truth because the
test of poetry.
0 comments:
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.